BLOG

High-drain vs high-capacity cells: how to choose

Short answer. A high-drain cell is built to deliver current and gives up some capacity to do it. A high-capacity cell stores more and is rated for less current. Work out the current each cell must supply in your device. If a capacity cell covers it with margin, choose capacity. If it does not, you need the power cell.

MAX. CONTINUOUS DISCHARGE · DATA SHEET FIGURES
P30B · 18650 · 3,000 mAh 30 A
NCR18650GA · 18650 · 3,450 mAh 10 A
P50B · 21700 · 5,000 mAh 60 A
EVE 50E · 21700 · 5,000 mAh 15 A
60XG · 21700 · 6,000 mAh 40 A
Capacities are typical figures. The Molicel ratings assume an 80 °C cut-off. The 60XG figure is its rating without a cut-off.

Why one cell cannot do both

The can is a fixed size. Thick electrode coatings hold more active material, which raises capacity and also raises resistance. Thin coatings and more current-collector area lower resistance, so the cell can deliver current without overheating, and they leave less room for active material. Internal resistance is the figure that separates the two types.

Five data sheets side by side

CELL SIZE CAPACITY, TYPICAL / MINIMUM MAX. CONTINUOUS DISCHARGE
Molicel P30B 18650 3,000 / 2,900 mAh 30 A with an 80 °C cut-off
Panasonic NCR18650GA 18650 3,450 / 3,350 mAh 10 A at 0 to 40 °C
Molicel P50B 21700 5,000 / 4,850 mAh 60 A with an 80 °C cut-off
EVE 50E 21700 5,000 / 4,900 mAh 15 A
TENPOWER 60XG 21700 6,000 / 5,900 mAh 40 A without a temperature cut-off, 60 A with a 75 °C cut-off

In the 18650 pair, the NCR18650GA holds 15% more than the P30B and is rated for a third of the current.

The gap is closing in the 21700 size

The P50B and the EVE 50E are both 5,000 mAh typical, and the P50B is rated for four times the current. The 60XG holds 6,000 mAh and is rated for 40 A. In this size a power cell no longer has to give up capacity. What it adds is a condition: the P50B's 60 A assumes an 80 °C cut-off, which takes a temperature sensor in the pack.

How to choose

  1. Find the current per cell: the device's draw divided by the number of cells in parallel.
  2. Shortlist the cells whose continuous rating is above that figure, with margin. Leave pulse figures out: pulse figures are never ratings.
  3. Read the condition on each rating: the temperature range and any cut-off.
  4. Among the cells that are left, compare capacity, typical and minimum.

Which type suits what

  • Power cells. Cordless tools, drones and high-output lights, where a few cells supply tens of amps.
  • Capacity cells. Packs with many cells in parallel, power banks and low-output lights, where each cell supplies a few amps for a long time.
Molicel INR-18650-P30B 18650 cellsPanasonic NCR18650GA 18650 cells
Molicel INR-18650-P30B, rated for 30 A with an 80 °C cut-off, and Panasonic NCR18650GA, rated for 10 A. The same size, built for different jobs.

Common questions

Can I use a high-drain cell in a low-drain device?

Yes. A current rating is a limit, not a draw. You give up some capacity: 3,000 against 3,450 mAh in the 18650 pair above.

Is a higher amp rating always better?

No. Rating beyond what the device draws adds nothing, and in the 18650 size it costs capacity.

Do high-drain cells run cooler?

At the same current, a cell with lower resistance makes less heat. That is the reason to choose one when the current per cell is high.

Sources

Molicel INR-18650-P30B, Panasonic NCR18650GA, Molicel INR-21700-P50B, EVE INR21700/50E and TENPOWER INR21700-60XG data sheets, linked from the product pages and the data sheet library. Percentages and ratios are arithmetic.

MORE FROM THE BLOG

Keep reading

ALL POSTS